If you think an HMRC VAT assessment is wrong, the decision letter starts a 30-day clock. Within it you can accept HMRC’s offer of a statutory review or appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax). Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is a third route, but for VAT it usually runs alongside an appeal and does not stop the time limits running.

For how an assessment can be tested on its figures, see our article on challenging HMRC VAT assessments.

The 30-Day Deadline

When HMRC notifies a VAT decision that can be appealed, such as an assessment, it must offer a review at the same time (section 83A of the VAT Act 1994). You then have 30 days from the date of the letter to do one of two things:

  • accept the review, by telling HMRC within the 30 days (section 83C), or
  • appeal to the tribunal (section 83G).

Once you have appealed, HMRC will not review the decision. If HMRC extends the review period before the 30 days run out, the time to appeal is extended too.

Option 1: A Statutory Review

An HMRC officer not involved in the original decision carries out the review. The officer can uphold, vary or cancel the decision, and must consider representations you make in time (section 83F).

HMRC has 45 days from receiving your acceptance to send its conclusions, unless you agree a different period. If it misses the deadline, the decision is treated as upheld and you can appeal. You cannot appeal until the review ends. If you disagree with the conclusions, you have 30 days from the date of the conclusion letter to appeal to the tribunal. HMRC does not collect the disputed VAT during the review.

Option 2: Appeal to the Tax Tribunal

For VAT you can appeal straight to the independent First-tier Tribunal (Tax). The notice of appeal must set out the decision you are appealing against, the result you want and your grounds, with a copy of the decision letter (rule 20 of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009).

Do you have to pay the VAT first?

Usually, yes. The tribunal will not hear an appeal against a VAT assessment until the VAT HMRC says is due is paid or deposited, unless HMRC accepts, or the tribunal decides, that paying would cause you hardship (section 84(3) and (3B)).

You apply to HMRC in writing and must show the hardship, usually with accounts and bank statements. If HMRC refuses, you can apply to the tribunal, whose decision on hardship is final. You need not wait for HMRC’s answer before appealing, but you must tell the tribunal you have applied. You do not have to pay a penalty before appealing against it.

Option 3: Alternative Dispute Resolution

ADR is HMRC’s mediation service. An HMRC officer trained in mediation helps you and the case officer reach agreement, without imposing a solution. ADR is not a statutory process, and HMRC can reject unsuitable applications.

During a compliance check, you can apply if progress has stalled. Once HMRC has made a decision you can appeal, its factsheet CC/FS21 says you can apply when:

  • you have appealed to the tribunal and it has acknowledged your appeal,
  • you accepted a review, it has ended, and you have then appealed and had the acknowledgement, or
  • HMRC has agreed to extend the period for accepting the review.

HMRC’s 2025 consultation explained that applicants who had not appealed first were rejected, to protect their 30-day time limit. ADR does not affect your right to a review or an appeal, but nothing in the VAT Act pauses the deadlines while you apply. If you have made a hardship application, HMRC asks you to wait for its outcome before applying.

Exclusions include appeals allocated as paper or basic cases, automatic penalties, civil evasion penalties and criminal investigations.

You apply online, or an adviser can apply for you. You commit to disclosing the relevant facts and evidence in writing before any mediation meeting, and to being available for a meeting within 90 days of acceptance. In our view, where you have already appealed, the appeal carries on if ADR ends without agreement.

Missed the Deadline?

HMRC must carry out a late review if you ask in writing and it is satisfied you had a reasonable excuse and asked without unreasonable delay once the excuse ended, provided you have not already appealed (section 83E). A late appeal needs the tribunal’s permission, and the notice of appeal must ask for it and explain the delay.

The tribunal normally follows the three-stage test in Martland v HMRC [2018] UKUT 178 (TCC): the length of the delay, the reasons for it, and then all the circumstances, including the particular importance of conducting litigation efficiently and of statutory time limits being respected. The starting point is that permission is not granted unless the tribunal is satisfied, on balance, that it should be. HMRC v Katib [2019] UKUT 189 (TCC) adds that an adviser’s failures are generally treated as the taxpayer’s own, so they are unlikely to be a good reason for the delay. In January 2026 the Court of Appeal confirmed the Martland approach, as amplified by Katib, in a VAT case, HMRC v MedPro Healthcare Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 14, saying a time limit “is there to be respected”.

Review or Appeal?

A review is usually quicker, but it is still HMRC looking at its own decision. Where the dispute is about the law, or HMRC has already set out its position in full, we think going straight to the tribunal often makes more sense.

When to Get an Adviser

An adviser is most useful where the amount is significant or the dispute turns on a point of law or on how HMRC built its figure. Our article on challenging HMRC VAT assessments shows how one assessment failed when it was tested.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do I have to challenge an HMRC VAT assessment?

Usually 30 days from the date of the decision letter. In that time you can accept HMRC’s offer of a statutory review or appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (Tax). If you take the review, you then have 30 days from the date of the review conclusion letter to appeal.

Does ADR stop the time limit for a VAT appeal?

No. Once HMRC has made an appealable VAT decision, it generally expects you to have appealed to the tribunal before it will accept an ADR application. ADR does not affect your right to appeal, but it does not extend the deadline.

Do I need an ADR consultant for a VAT dispute?

No. Anyone can apply for ADR, and the mediator is an HMRC officer trained in mediation. An adviser can apply for you.

Do I have to pay the VAT before appealing an assessment?

Usually, yes. The tribunal will not hear an appeal against a VAT assessment until the VAT is paid or deposited, unless HMRC or the tribunal accepts that paying would cause hardship. You do not have to pay a penalty before appealing against it.

Accountants: our VAT Helpline for Accountants answers questions like this on client files, on a retainer.

Law and HMRC guidance checked as at 11 November 2026. This is general information, not advice for your circumstances.