Most people never think about which country's VAT is on their phone bill. For mobile operators and eSIM sellers, it is a real question. The UK and the EU follow broadly the same rule for telecoms sold to consumers, but they apply it differently, and since Brexit the gap between them can mean VAT is charged twice on the same roaming, or not charged at all.
We advise operators and other businesses on cross-border VAT as part of our VAT advisory services. This article explains where the UK and EU rules part company.
The Basic Rule: Telecoms Are Taxed Where the Customer Lives
The place of supply rules decide which country's VAT applies to a service. For telecommunication services sold to consumers (often called B2C supplies), the UK rule is that VAT is due in the country where the customer usually lives.
“Telecommunication services” is a wide term. It covers phone calls, mobile data, broadband, internet access and roaming. Radio and TV broadcasting and digital (electronically supplied) services follow the same basic rule.
So a mobile contract sold to someone who lives in Leeds is taxed in the UK. A contract sold to someone who lives in Lyon is not, on this basic rule, whichever company sells it.
What Is the “Use and Enjoyment” Rule?
A use and enjoyment rule overrides the normal place of supply and taxes a service where it is actually used. Until 2017 the UK applied one to telecoms used outside the EU. If a UK resident made a call while on holiday in the USA, that call was treated as used outside the UK and no UK VAT was charged on it.
From 1 November 2017 the UK removed this rule for consumers. HMRC's reasoning was that the internationally agreed approach is to tax mobile phone use where the user lives, and that keeping a use and enjoyment rule could lead to double taxation. It also said the old rule was being exploited to avoid UK VAT.
The result is simple. If you live in the UK and buy your mobile contract from a UK operator, UK VAT applies to your calls, texts and data, including roaming, wherever in the world you use your phone.
The use and enjoyment rule still applies to telecoms sold to businesses, and to radio and TV broadcasting.
How the EU Treats Roaming
The EU starts from the same place: telecoms sold to consumers are taxed where the customer lives. But EU law also gives each member state an option, used to prevent double taxation, non-taxation or distortion of competition, to tax services that are used and enjoyed in its territory, where the customer lives outside the EU.
The Court of Justice confirmed how far this goes in the SK Telecom case (2021). A South Korean operator supplied roaming to South Korean customers visiting Austria, and Austria treated that roaming as taxable in Austria, refusing the operator a VAT refund on that basis. The Court said Austria was entitled to do so, even for a short stay, where it stops the roaming going untaxed in the EU, and that tax charged in South Korea is disregarded in deciding that.
Austria's courts have continued to uphold that position. Member states are not obliged to use the option, so the answer can vary from country to country.
Where UK and EU VAT Rules Collide
Can mobile roaming be taxed twice?
Yes. Before Brexit, the UK was part of the EU, so a UK customer's roaming was treated as supplied inside the EU and this option could not be used. Now that the UK is outside the EU, it can be.
Take a UK resident on a UK contract who spends a fortnight in Vienna. The UK charges VAT on the whole bill, because the customer lives in the UK. Austria can also charge VAT on the roaming used in Austria, because it was used there. Nothing in the UK rules gives relief for the Austrian tax. The same roaming can be taxed twice.
How is VAT charged on eSIMs and foreign SIM cards?
The UK and EU also look at where a consumer lives in different ways. EU rules presume a customer lives in the country of their SIM card, based on the SIM's network code. In the UK, the legislation taxes these supplies where the customer actually lives, because the EU regulation containing the SIM card presumption stopped being part of UK law at the end of 2020. HMRC's published guidance, though, still says businesses can presume a supply through a mobile phone is made where the SIM card's country code points. That guidance has not been fully updated since Brexit and gives no legal basis, but until HMRC changes it, the UK position is not settled.
So an EU company selling a data plan or travel eSIM with an EU SIM to someone who lives in Manchester may charge EU VAT under the EU presumption. If the UK applies the actual residence test, it treats the same sale as a UK supply, and the seller may then have to register for UK VAT. There is no minimum turnover before that applies to an overseas business. If HMRC's SIM card presumption is applied instead, the UK and EU agree and the gap closes. The EU allows the seller to overturn the presumption with three pieces of consistent evidence of where the customer really lives, but it has to act to do so.
Can a telecoms supply escape VAT altogether?
It may. Someone who has moved to Spain for good, with no UK address left, but kept a UK mobile contract no longer lives in the UK, so on the actual residence test no UK VAT is due. Under the EU rules, their UK SIM card points to the UK, so EU VAT may not be due either. Unless the country where the phone is used applies its own use and enjoyment rule, the supply may not be taxed anywhere. If HMRC's SIM card presumption is applied instead, the UK SIM points back to the UK and UK VAT would be due.
Why This Matters
These mismatches matter most to:
- UK mobile operators and MVNOs whose customers roam in the EU
- EU operators and eSIM sellers with customers who live in the UK
- Businesses selling telecoms or connectivity bundles to consumers in more than one country
The amounts on a single bill are small, but across a customer base they add up, and VAT that was not charged at the time is hard to recover from consumers afterwards.
A Practical Checklist
- Know where your customers live, and keep evidence of it. This decides which country taxes the supply.
- Check which EU countries your customers roam in, and whether those countries apply a use and enjoyment rule to telecoms.
- If you sell to UK residents from outside the UK, check whether you need to register for UK VAT.
- If you rely on the EU SIM card presumption, consider whether the evidence shows the customer lives somewhere else.
- Review your contract terms, so you know whether any extra VAT can be passed on or stays with you.
For help reviewing where your own supplies are taxed, see our VAT advice for businesses.
Accountants: our VAT Helpline for Accountants answers questions like this on client files, on a retainer.
