Many brands and retailers charge VAT at 20% on protein powders, because HMRC treats a lot of sports nutrition as standard-rated. A tax tribunal decision in the Global by Nature case says that, for many protein powders, this is wrong. If your business has been charging VAT on low-sugar protein powders, you may be able to claim some of it back from HMRC.
We advise brands and retailers on the VAT liability of food and drink products as part of our VAT advisory services. This article sets out what the decision says and who it could help.
Is Protein Powder Zero-Rated or Standard-Rated?
Most food is zero-rated for VAT, which means no VAT is charged on it. “Food” includes drinks, but the law then takes certain drinks back out of the zero rate, so they are standard-rated at 20%.
Two of those exceptions matter for protein powders:
- “Other beverages”, including powders for making them
- Sports drinks that are advertised or marketed as products designed to enhance physical performance, accelerate recovery after exercise or build bulk, including powders for making them
HMRC already accepts that a protein powder with real nutritional value, mixed with water and drunk, can be food rather than a beverage, although it says a drinkable product can still be standard-rated as a beverage in some cases. The fight has been over the second exception, sports drinks. HMRC's view has been that a protein powder marketed to people who train is a sports drink, and so carries 20% VAT.
The Global by Nature Case
Global by Nature Ltd sells plant-based protein powders under the Sunwarrior brand. It had been charging VAT on its protein powders, then asked HMRC to repay the VAT it had paid between October 2016 and September 2020. HMRC accepted some of the products were zero-rated, but refused the claim for three Sunwarrior powders. The VAT in dispute was almost £800,000.
HMRC's argument was that those products were sports drinks because of the way they were advertised and marketed.
In January 2025 the First-tier Tribunal disagreed. It decided that the law only catches products that are sports drinks in the ordinary sense, and found, on the evidence before it, that a sports drink is a drink containing a significant amount of carbohydrate (usually sugar), which may also contain salts such as sodium and potassium. Marketing only matters once a product is a sports drink in the first place.
The Sunwarrior powders were between 71% and 81% protein, with no more than 1g of carbohydrate per serving. They were not sports drinks, and HMRC did not argue that they were beverages, so they were zero-rated, and Global by Nature won its appeal.
What HMRC Still Says
HMRC's own guidance has not changed. Its VAT Food Manual, last updated in July 2024 (before the decision), still says that “a product designed to build bulk and marketed at gym users is standard-rated”.
The Global by Nature decision is from the First-tier Tribunal, so it only binds the parties to that case. Another tribunal could reach a different view. That said, we have found no record of HMRC appealing it: there is nothing on the Upper Tribunal's register of cases or on HMRC's own list of VAT appeals.
So there is now a clear gap between HMRC's guidance and the tribunal's reading of the law. Businesses on the right side of that gap may be paying VAT they do not owe.
Which Products Could Benefit?
On the tribunal's reasoning, the strongest position is for low-carbohydrate protein powders, such as whey, plant and vegan protein powders with little or no sugar. That applies even if they are sold to gym users.
High-carbohydrate products are different. Mass gainers and carbohydrate recovery drinks are much closer to what the tribunal described as a sports drink, and if they are marketed for performance, recovery or building bulk they may well stay standard-rated.
Every product needs looking at on its own facts, including its nutritional content per serving and how its recipe and packaging changed over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is protein powder subject to VAT?
It depends on the product. Protein powders with real nutritional value can be zero-rated as food. HMRC treats many sports nutrition products as standard-rated sports drinks, but the tribunal in Global by Nature held that the low-carbohydrate protein powders in that case were not sports drinks and, as HMRC did not argue that they were beverages, they were zero-rated.
Can I claim a VAT refund on protein powder?
Possibly, if your business has been charging and paying VAT at 20% on protein powders that should have been zero-rated. The claim is made by the business that paid the VAT to HMRC, such as the brand or the retailer. Claims can only go back four years, and HMRC can refuse to repay where the refund would leave the business better off because the VAT was passed on to customers. Consumers cannot claim VAT back from HMRC.
Does marketing to gym users make protein powder standard-rated?
Not on its own, according to the tribunal. Marketing only matters if the product is a sports drink in the first place, which the tribunal said means a drink with a significant amount of carbohydrate. HMRC's guidance still takes the opposite view, so expect resistance.
Could Your Business Be Owed a Refund?
If you sell low-sugar protein powders and have been charging 20% VAT on them, it is worth checking whether you have a claim. The four-year time limit means every month that passes can reduce what you can recover. Because HMRC's guidance still takes the opposite view, it may refuse a claim based on the decision, so be prepared to appeal.
Before making a claim, think about who actually bore the VAT. HMRC has a defence where a refund would unjustly enrich the business, for example where the VAT was built into the shelf price and paid by customers. How strong that defence is depends on how your prices were set, so it is worth working through before the claim goes in.
You will also need evidence for each product across the whole claim period, in particular its nutritional information per serving and how it was packaged and marketed.
A Practical Checklist
- List every protein product you sell, with its carbohydrate and sugar content per serving
- Separate low-carbohydrate protein powders from mass gainers and carbohydrate drinks
- Gather packaging, labels and marketing for each product over the last four years
- Check how VAT was built into your prices, so you can deal with the unjust enrichment question
- Consider your VAT treatment going forward, bearing in mind HMRC's guidance has not changed
For a second view on your product range or a refund claim, see our VAT advice for businesses.
